Un-drafted free agents - post em here
-
eastcoast128
- Posts: 1,570
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2018 1:38 pm
- Has given High Fives: 16 times
- Received High Fives: 54 times
-
raiders72
- Posts: 852
- Joined: Sun Apr 24, 2016 4:29 pm
- Has given High Fives: 1 time
- Received High Fives: 73 times
Good info thanks again to chuck!
- These users gave a High Five to the author raiders72 for the post:
- GoodTimeCharlie
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
SAM JOHNSON | P | VALPARAISO
• HEIGHT: 6-4
• WEIGHT: 230
Scouting Report: Summary
Johnson was Valparaiso’s full-time punter, handling all duties with consistency. In 2025, he averaged 41.2 yards per punt, with a long of 64 yards and 15 punts downed inside the 20. His ability to control field position was a key asset for the Crusaders.
Strengths
• Reliable mechanics and consistent punting motion.
• Good situational control, pinning opponents deep.
• Durable — handled full punting load without issue.
• Strong frame (6-4, 230) for the position.
Weaknesses
• Average leg strength compared to elite FBS punters.
• Limited versatility (not a dual-role kicker/punter).
• Small-school competition level raises transition questions.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Thomas Morstead (early-career profile) — reliable, technically sound punter without elite power.
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a developmental punter with consistency and control, especially for directional and situational punting.
Key Takeaway
Sam Johnson is a technically sound punter with reliable mechanics and situational control. While his leg strength may not match top-tier prospects, his consistency and ability to flip field position give him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a developmental punter at the next level.
*3 year old video
• HEIGHT: 6-4
• WEIGHT: 230
Scouting Report: Summary
Johnson was Valparaiso’s full-time punter, handling all duties with consistency. In 2025, he averaged 41.2 yards per punt, with a long of 64 yards and 15 punts downed inside the 20. His ability to control field position was a key asset for the Crusaders.
Strengths
• Reliable mechanics and consistent punting motion.
• Good situational control, pinning opponents deep.
• Durable — handled full punting load without issue.
• Strong frame (6-4, 230) for the position.
Weaknesses
• Average leg strength compared to elite FBS punters.
• Limited versatility (not a dual-role kicker/punter).
• Small-school competition level raises transition questions.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Thomas Morstead (early-career profile) — reliable, technically sound punter without elite power.
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a developmental punter with consistency and control, especially for directional and situational punting.
Key Takeaway
Sam Johnson is a technically sound punter with reliable mechanics and situational control. While his leg strength may not match top-tier prospects, his consistency and ability to flip field position give him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a developmental punter at the next level.
*3 year old video
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
MARSEL MCDUFFIE | LB | UNLV
• HEIGHT: 6-1
• WEIGHT: 235
Scouting Report: Summary
McDuffie was a standout defender for UNLV, earning Second Team All-Mountain West honors in 2025. He led the Rebels with 112 tackles, 5.5 tackles for loss, 2 sacks, and 2 interceptions, showing both range and playmaking ability. A multi-year starter, he consistently produced across his career, including 89 tackles in 2023 and 46 tackles in 2024. His instincts and leadership made him one of the anchors of UNLV’s defense.
Strengths
• High-volume tackler with strong instincts and awareness.
• Playmaker: 2 INTs, 5 PBUs, and 3 fumble recoveries in 2025.
• Durable multi-year starter with leadership traits.
• Versatility to play inside linebacker and contribute on special teams.
• Good recognition in zone coverage and run fits.
Weaknesses
• Average athletic profile compared to top linebacker prospects.
• Limited pass-rush production (2 sacks in 2025).
• Coverage limitations against faster RBs and tight ends.
• Needs added strength to handle NFL-level physicality.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 6–7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Josey Jewell (productive, instinctive LB with average athleticism).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a depth linebacker who can contribute on special teams and provide reliable tackling in rotational packages.
Key Takeaway
Marsel McDuffie is a tough, instinctive linebacker with proven production and leadership. His tackling consistency and versatility give him a path to stick as a depth LB and special teams contributor at the next level.
• HEIGHT: 6-1
• WEIGHT: 235
Scouting Report: Summary
McDuffie was a standout defender for UNLV, earning Second Team All-Mountain West honors in 2025. He led the Rebels with 112 tackles, 5.5 tackles for loss, 2 sacks, and 2 interceptions, showing both range and playmaking ability. A multi-year starter, he consistently produced across his career, including 89 tackles in 2023 and 46 tackles in 2024. His instincts and leadership made him one of the anchors of UNLV’s defense.
Strengths
• High-volume tackler with strong instincts and awareness.
• Playmaker: 2 INTs, 5 PBUs, and 3 fumble recoveries in 2025.
• Durable multi-year starter with leadership traits.
• Versatility to play inside linebacker and contribute on special teams.
• Good recognition in zone coverage and run fits.
Weaknesses
• Average athletic profile compared to top linebacker prospects.
• Limited pass-rush production (2 sacks in 2025).
• Coverage limitations against faster RBs and tight ends.
• Needs added strength to handle NFL-level physicality.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 6–7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Josey Jewell (productive, instinctive LB with average athleticism).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a depth linebacker who can contribute on special teams and provide reliable tackling in rotational packages.
Key Takeaway
Marsel McDuffie is a tough, instinctive linebacker with proven production and leadership. His tackling consistency and versatility give him a path to stick as a depth LB and special teams contributor at the next level.
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
GAVIN LIPKIN | LS | SOUTHERN UTAH
• HEIGHT: 6-4
• WEIGHT: 241
Scouting Report: Summary
Lipkin has been Southern Utah’s starting long snapper since 2022, appearing in every game over multiple seasons. He earned Second Team All-UAC honors in 2024 and was named to the Phil Steele Preseason First Team All-UAC in 2025. He’s also a CSC Academic All-District selection, highlighting his discipline and leadership off the field. His size and consistency make him a reliable specialist prospect.
Strengths
• Four-year starter with clean, consistent snapping mechanics.
• Prototypical long snapper frame at 6’4”, 241.
• Durable and dependable, never missed a game.
• Special teams contributor beyond snapping, credited with tackles in coverage.
• Academic recognition underscores work ethic and character.
Weaknesses
• Specialist role limits positional versatility.
• Small-school competition level compared to FBS long snappers.
• Limited exposure to high-pressure national stages.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent / Specialist Tryout.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Rick Lovato (steady, technically sound long snapper).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a developmental long snapper with size, consistency, and durability.
Key Takeaway
Gavin Lipkin is a reliable, technically sound long snapper with proven durability and leadership. His combination of size, consistency, and academic recognition makes him a legitimate candidate to compete for an NFL roster spot as a specialist.
*4 year old video. He looks about 12. Hahhaa
• HEIGHT: 6-4
• WEIGHT: 241
Scouting Report: Summary
Lipkin has been Southern Utah’s starting long snapper since 2022, appearing in every game over multiple seasons. He earned Second Team All-UAC honors in 2024 and was named to the Phil Steele Preseason First Team All-UAC in 2025. He’s also a CSC Academic All-District selection, highlighting his discipline and leadership off the field. His size and consistency make him a reliable specialist prospect.
Strengths
• Four-year starter with clean, consistent snapping mechanics.
• Prototypical long snapper frame at 6’4”, 241.
• Durable and dependable, never missed a game.
• Special teams contributor beyond snapping, credited with tackles in coverage.
• Academic recognition underscores work ethic and character.
Weaknesses
• Specialist role limits positional versatility.
• Small-school competition level compared to FBS long snappers.
• Limited exposure to high-pressure national stages.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent / Specialist Tryout.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Rick Lovato (steady, technically sound long snapper).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a developmental long snapper with size, consistency, and durability.
Key Takeaway
Gavin Lipkin is a reliable, technically sound long snapper with proven durability and leadership. His combination of size, consistency, and academic recognition makes him a legitimate candidate to compete for an NFL roster spot as a specialist.
*4 year old video. He looks about 12. Hahhaa
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
PATRICK GURD | TE/FB | CINCINNATI
• HEIGHT: 6-4 (6036 official)
• WEIGHT: 244–250
• HANDS: 9 ¼
• ARM: 31 ⅞
• SPAN: 78
• FORTY: 4.80 (range 4.78–4.82)
• 20YD: 2.77
• 10YD: 1.69
• VERT: 37.5
• BROAD: 10’3”
• SHUT: 4.34
• 3CONE: 6.96
• BENCH: 22 reps
Scouting Report: Summary
Gurd began his career at Ohio State, where he appeared in 27 games and contributed to the Buckeyes’ 2024 National Championship run. He transferred to Cincinnati for more playing time, serving primarily as a blocking tight end/fullback. In 2025, he played in 12 games with two starts, recording 3 catches for 46 yards, including a 23-yard reception in the Liberty Bowl. His athletic testing numbers show above-average explosiveness for his size, though his receiving production has been limited.
Strengths
• Versatility: Can line up as TE, FB, or H-back.
• Blocking ability: Strong frame and leverage in run game.
• Explosiveness: 37.5” vertical and 10’3” broad jump highlight athletic upside.
• Experience: Played in CFP games at Ohio State and contributed at Cincinnati.
• Academic honors: Four-time OSU Scholar-Athlete, three-time Academic All-Big Ten.
Weaknesses
• Limited receiving production: Only 3 catches in 2025.
• Not a dynamic route runner: More of a short-yardage option.
• Projection as role player: Ceiling may be capped as a blocking specialist.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Nick Bellore (FB/TE hybrid, special teams contributor).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a versatile blocking TE/FB who can contribute on special teams and short-yardage packages.
Key Takeaway
Patrick Gurd is a versatile tight end/fullback with legitimate athletic testing numbers and proven blocking ability. While his receiving production is modest, his size, explosiveness, and experience at both Ohio State and Cincinnati make him a candidate to earn a roster spot as a hybrid TE/FB and special teams contributor.
• HEIGHT: 6-4 (6036 official)
• WEIGHT: 244–250
• HANDS: 9 ¼
• ARM: 31 ⅞
• SPAN: 78
• FORTY: 4.80 (range 4.78–4.82)
• 20YD: 2.77
• 10YD: 1.69
• VERT: 37.5
• BROAD: 10’3”
• SHUT: 4.34
• 3CONE: 6.96
• BENCH: 22 reps
Scouting Report: Summary
Gurd began his career at Ohio State, where he appeared in 27 games and contributed to the Buckeyes’ 2024 National Championship run. He transferred to Cincinnati for more playing time, serving primarily as a blocking tight end/fullback. In 2025, he played in 12 games with two starts, recording 3 catches for 46 yards, including a 23-yard reception in the Liberty Bowl. His athletic testing numbers show above-average explosiveness for his size, though his receiving production has been limited.
Strengths
• Versatility: Can line up as TE, FB, or H-back.
• Blocking ability: Strong frame and leverage in run game.
• Explosiveness: 37.5” vertical and 10’3” broad jump highlight athletic upside.
• Experience: Played in CFP games at Ohio State and contributed at Cincinnati.
• Academic honors: Four-time OSU Scholar-Athlete, three-time Academic All-Big Ten.
Weaknesses
• Limited receiving production: Only 3 catches in 2025.
• Not a dynamic route runner: More of a short-yardage option.
• Projection as role player: Ceiling may be capped as a blocking specialist.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Nick Bellore (FB/TE hybrid, special teams contributor).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a versatile blocking TE/FB who can contribute on special teams and short-yardage packages.
Key Takeaway
Patrick Gurd is a versatile tight end/fullback with legitimate athletic testing numbers and proven blocking ability. While his receiving production is modest, his size, explosiveness, and experience at both Ohio State and Cincinnati make him a candidate to earn a roster spot as a hybrid TE/FB and special teams contributor.
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
MILES DAVIS | RB | UTAH STATE
• HEIGHT: 5-11
• WEIGHT: 215
Scouting Report: Summary
Davis transferred from BYU to Utah State and broke out in 2025, earning Second-Team All-Mountain West honors. He rushed for 731 yards and 8 touchdowns, while adding 28 receptions for 201 yards and 3 receiving scores, finishing with over 1,000 all-purpose yards and 11 total TDs. Across his career, he played in 40 games, totaling 1,200 rushing yards, 10 rushing TDs, and 44 receptions for 332 yards and 4 receiving TDs.
Strengths
• Versatile back with rushing and receiving ability.
• Explosive games: three 100-yard rushing performances in 2025.
• All-purpose threat: career-high 184 yards vs. UTEP.
• Experienced: 40 career games across BYU and Utah State.
• Recognized academically and athletically (All-Mountain West honors).
Weaknesses
• Durability concerns from limited touches earlier in career.
• Solid but not elite size/frame for NFL RB standards.
• Consistency — peak production came only in final season.
• Blocking ability in pass protection remains untested.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Tyler Ervin (versatile RB with receiving and return skills).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a change-of-pace back who can contribute on special teams and provide depth in both rushing and receiving roles.
Key Takeaway
Miles Davis is a versatile, productive back who proved himself as a senior at Utah State. His ability to contribute as a runner, receiver, and returner gives him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a depth RB and special teams contributor at the next level.
• HEIGHT: 5-11
• WEIGHT: 215
Scouting Report: Summary
Davis transferred from BYU to Utah State and broke out in 2025, earning Second-Team All-Mountain West honors. He rushed for 731 yards and 8 touchdowns, while adding 28 receptions for 201 yards and 3 receiving scores, finishing with over 1,000 all-purpose yards and 11 total TDs. Across his career, he played in 40 games, totaling 1,200 rushing yards, 10 rushing TDs, and 44 receptions for 332 yards and 4 receiving TDs.
Strengths
• Versatile back with rushing and receiving ability.
• Explosive games: three 100-yard rushing performances in 2025.
• All-purpose threat: career-high 184 yards vs. UTEP.
• Experienced: 40 career games across BYU and Utah State.
• Recognized academically and athletically (All-Mountain West honors).
Weaknesses
• Durability concerns from limited touches earlier in career.
• Solid but not elite size/frame for NFL RB standards.
• Consistency — peak production came only in final season.
• Blocking ability in pass protection remains untested.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Tyler Ervin (versatile RB with receiving and return skills).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a change-of-pace back who can contribute on special teams and provide depth in both rushing and receiving roles.
Key Takeaway
Miles Davis is a versatile, productive back who proved himself as a senior at Utah State. His ability to contribute as a runner, receiver, and returner gives him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a depth RB and special teams contributor at the next level.
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
JADEN KELLER | LB | VIRGINIA TECH
• HEIGHT: 6-2 (6022 official)
• WEIGHT: 237
• HANDS: 8 ⅝
• ARM: 32
• SPAN: 77 ⅞
• FORTY: 4.51 (range 4.47–4.56)
• 20YD: 2.49
• 10YD: 1.50
• VERT: 35.5
• BROAD: 9’11”
• SHUT: 4.31
• 3CONE: 6.99
• BENCH: 21 reps
Scouting Report: Summary
Keller developed into a key defensive leader for Virginia Tech, appearing in 61 career games. In 2024, he led the Hokies with 83 tackles, adding 1.5 TFLs, 2 fumble recoveries, and a critical fourth-down stop against Boston College. In 2025, he followed up with 50 tackles, 2.5 TFLs, 0.5 sacks, and a forced fumble. His athletic testing numbers highlight above-average speed and explosiveness for his size, making him a versatile linebacker prospect.
Strengths
• High-volume tackler: Led Virginia Tech in tackles in 2024.
• Explosiveness: 35.5” vertical and 9’11” broad jump.
• Durability: Played in 61 career games across five seasons.
• Versatility: Experience at both inside and outside linebacker.
• Leadership: Consistent starter and defensive anchor.
Weaknesses
• Coverage limitations: More effective in zone than man coverage.
• Pass-rush production: Modest sack totals (0.5 in 2025).
• Frame: Solid but not elite size compared to NFL linebackers.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 6–7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Logan Wilson (instinctive LB with solid athleticism).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a versatile linebacker who can contribute on special teams and provide depth in rotational packages.
Key Takeaway
Jaden Keller is a durable, instinctive linebacker with proven production at Virginia Tech. His tackling consistency, leadership, and explosiveness give him a path to stick as a depth LB and special teams contributor at the next level.
• HEIGHT: 6-2 (6022 official)
• WEIGHT: 237
• HANDS: 8 ⅝
• ARM: 32
• SPAN: 77 ⅞
• FORTY: 4.51 (range 4.47–4.56)
• 20YD: 2.49
• 10YD: 1.50
• VERT: 35.5
• BROAD: 9’11”
• SHUT: 4.31
• 3CONE: 6.99
• BENCH: 21 reps
Scouting Report: Summary
Keller developed into a key defensive leader for Virginia Tech, appearing in 61 career games. In 2024, he led the Hokies with 83 tackles, adding 1.5 TFLs, 2 fumble recoveries, and a critical fourth-down stop against Boston College. In 2025, he followed up with 50 tackles, 2.5 TFLs, 0.5 sacks, and a forced fumble. His athletic testing numbers highlight above-average speed and explosiveness for his size, making him a versatile linebacker prospect.
Strengths
• High-volume tackler: Led Virginia Tech in tackles in 2024.
• Explosiveness: 35.5” vertical and 9’11” broad jump.
• Durability: Played in 61 career games across five seasons.
• Versatility: Experience at both inside and outside linebacker.
• Leadership: Consistent starter and defensive anchor.
Weaknesses
• Coverage limitations: More effective in zone than man coverage.
• Pass-rush production: Modest sack totals (0.5 in 2025).
• Frame: Solid but not elite size compared to NFL linebackers.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 6–7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Logan Wilson (instinctive LB with solid athleticism).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a versatile linebacker who can contribute on special teams and provide depth in rotational packages.
Key Takeaway
Jaden Keller is a durable, instinctive linebacker with proven production at Virginia Tech. His tackling consistency, leadership, and explosiveness give him a path to stick as a depth LB and special teams contributor at the next level.
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
ERIC BUTLER | S | SAN DIEGO STATE
• HEIGHT: 6-2 (6017 official)
• WEIGHT: 190
• HANDS: 10 ⅛
• ARM: 31
• SPAN: 77 ⅝
• FORTY: 4.59 (range 4.54–4.64)
• 20YD: 2.64
• 10YD: 1.59
• VERT: 32
• BROAD: 10’7”
• SHUT: 4.24
• 3CONE: 7.09
• BENCH: 12 reps
Scouting Report: Summary
Butler was a steady defensive presence for San Diego State, appearing in 49 career games. In 2025, he recorded 42 tackles and 6 pass breakups, while in 2024 he posted 49 tackles, 1 interception, and 3 PBUs. His athletic testing numbers highlight solid speed and explosiveness, making him a versatile safety prospect with special teams upside.
Strengths
• Size and length: 6’2” frame with 77 ⅝” wingspan.
• Athleticism: 4.59 forty, 32” vertical, and 10’7” broad jump.
• Coverage ability: 9 career pass breakups, showing ball skills.
• Durability: Multi-year starter with consistent production.
• Versatility: Experience at both free safety and strong safety, plus special teams.
Weaknesses
• Turnover production: Only 1 career interception.
• Run support: Average tackling numbers compared to top safeties.
• Strength: 12 bench reps suggest room for added upper-body power.
• Small-school exposure: Less national spotlight compared to Power Five safeties.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 6–7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Julian Blackmon (rangy safety with solid athleticism but modest turnover production).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a versatile safety who can contribute in sub-packages and on special teams.
Key Takeaway
Eric Butler is a rangy, athletic safety for San Diego State. While his turnover creation is limited, his size, speed, and versatility give him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a depth safety and special teams contributor.
• HEIGHT: 6-2 (6017 official)
• WEIGHT: 190
• HANDS: 10 ⅛
• ARM: 31
• SPAN: 77 ⅝
• FORTY: 4.59 (range 4.54–4.64)
• 20YD: 2.64
• 10YD: 1.59
• VERT: 32
• BROAD: 10’7”
• SHUT: 4.24
• 3CONE: 7.09
• BENCH: 12 reps
Scouting Report: Summary
Butler was a steady defensive presence for San Diego State, appearing in 49 career games. In 2025, he recorded 42 tackles and 6 pass breakups, while in 2024 he posted 49 tackles, 1 interception, and 3 PBUs. His athletic testing numbers highlight solid speed and explosiveness, making him a versatile safety prospect with special teams upside.
Strengths
• Size and length: 6’2” frame with 77 ⅝” wingspan.
• Athleticism: 4.59 forty, 32” vertical, and 10’7” broad jump.
• Coverage ability: 9 career pass breakups, showing ball skills.
• Durability: Multi-year starter with consistent production.
• Versatility: Experience at both free safety and strong safety, plus special teams.
Weaknesses
• Turnover production: Only 1 career interception.
• Run support: Average tackling numbers compared to top safeties.
• Strength: 12 bench reps suggest room for added upper-body power.
• Small-school exposure: Less national spotlight compared to Power Five safeties.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Round 6–7 / Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Julian Blackmon (rangy safety with solid athleticism but modest turnover production).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a versatile safety who can contribute in sub-packages and on special teams.
Key Takeaway
Eric Butler is a rangy, athletic safety for San Diego State. While his turnover creation is limited, his size, speed, and versatility give him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a depth safety and special teams contributor.
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
MALCOLM GILLIE | WR | COASTAL CAROLINA
• HEIGHT: 6-1 to 6-2
• WEIGHT: 200–204
Scouting Report: Summary
Gillie transferred to Coastal Carolina after a standout season at Ball State, where he was named 2024 MAC Special Teams Player of the Year and First-Team All-MAC as a kickoff returner. At Coastal in 2025, he appeared in all 13 games, catching 8 passes for 161 yards and 2 touchdowns, while returning 18 kickoffs for 467 yards and a touchdown. His explosiveness as a returner and ability to stretch the field vertically make him a versatile weapon.
Strengths
• Explosiveness: Career highlight includes a 96-yard kickoff return TD vs. Georgia Southern (2025) and a 100-yard return TD at Ball State (2023).
• Versatility: Contributes as both a wide receiver and return specialist.
• Big-play ability: Averaged 20.1 yards per catch in 2025.
• Experience: Played at Ellsworth CC, Ball State, and Coastal Carolina, with production at each stop.
• Recognition: 2024 MAC Special Teams Player of the Year, 2025 All-Sun Belt Honorable Mention.
Weaknesses
• Limited receiving volume: Only 8 catches in 2025.
• Route running: More of a vertical threat than polished possession receiver.
• Consistency: Production fluctuated across seasons.
• Projection: May be viewed primarily as a return specialist at the next level.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Andre Roberts (return specialist with receiving depth ability).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a dynamic returner who can also provide depth at wide receiver.
Key Takeaway
Malcolm Gillie is a dynamic return specialist with proven big-play ability and vertical receiving skills. While his receiving production is modest, his explosiveness on special teams gives him a clear path to compete for a roster spot as a returner and depth wideout.
*Fast is good. We haven’t had a dynamic return man since what, Brown?
• HEIGHT: 6-1 to 6-2
• WEIGHT: 200–204
Scouting Report: Summary
Gillie transferred to Coastal Carolina after a standout season at Ball State, where he was named 2024 MAC Special Teams Player of the Year and First-Team All-MAC as a kickoff returner. At Coastal in 2025, he appeared in all 13 games, catching 8 passes for 161 yards and 2 touchdowns, while returning 18 kickoffs for 467 yards and a touchdown. His explosiveness as a returner and ability to stretch the field vertically make him a versatile weapon.
Strengths
• Explosiveness: Career highlight includes a 96-yard kickoff return TD vs. Georgia Southern (2025) and a 100-yard return TD at Ball State (2023).
• Versatility: Contributes as both a wide receiver and return specialist.
• Big-play ability: Averaged 20.1 yards per catch in 2025.
• Experience: Played at Ellsworth CC, Ball State, and Coastal Carolina, with production at each stop.
• Recognition: 2024 MAC Special Teams Player of the Year, 2025 All-Sun Belt Honorable Mention.
Weaknesses
• Limited receiving volume: Only 8 catches in 2025.
• Route running: More of a vertical threat than polished possession receiver.
• Consistency: Production fluctuated across seasons.
• Projection: May be viewed primarily as a return specialist at the next level.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Andre Roberts (return specialist with receiving depth ability).
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a dynamic returner who can also provide depth at wide receiver.
Key Takeaway
Malcolm Gillie is a dynamic return specialist with proven big-play ability and vertical receiving skills. While his receiving production is modest, his explosiveness on special teams gives him a clear path to compete for a roster spot as a returner and depth wideout.
*Fast is good. We haven’t had a dynamic return man since what, Brown?
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
JAMES PLATTE | P | THE CITADEL
• HEIGHT: 6-0
• WEIGHT: 200
Scouting Report: Summary
Platte was The Citadel’s primary punter, handling full-time duties across multiple seasons. In 2025, he averaged 40.8 yards per punt, with a long of 61 yards and 14 punts downed inside the 20. His consistency and ability to control field position were key assets for the Bulldogs’ special teams unit.
Strengths
• Reliable mechanics and consistent punting motion.
• Good situational control, pinning opponents deep.
• Durable — handled full punting load without issue.
• Solid frame (6-0, 200) for the position.
Weaknesses
• Average leg strength compared to elite FBS punters.
• Limited versatility (not a dual-role kicker/punter).
• Small-school competition level raises transition questions.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Thomas Morstead (early-career profile) — reliable, technically sound punter without elite power.
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a developmental punter with consistency and control, especially for directional and situational punting.
Key Takeaway
James Platte is a technically sound punter with reliable mechanics and situational control. While his leg strength may not match top-tier prospects, his consistency and ability to flip field position give him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a developmental punter at the next level.
*A “lefty”. It’s might be silly, but quite a few hours later and this dude’s ability to perfectly place a punt is still impressed upon me.
• HEIGHT: 6-0
• WEIGHT: 200
Scouting Report: Summary
Platte was The Citadel’s primary punter, handling full-time duties across multiple seasons. In 2025, he averaged 40.8 yards per punt, with a long of 61 yards and 14 punts downed inside the 20. His consistency and ability to control field position were key assets for the Bulldogs’ special teams unit.
Strengths
• Reliable mechanics and consistent punting motion.
• Good situational control, pinning opponents deep.
• Durable — handled full punting load without issue.
• Solid frame (6-0, 200) for the position.
Weaknesses
• Average leg strength compared to elite FBS punters.
• Limited versatility (not a dual-role kicker/punter).
• Small-school competition level raises transition questions.
Projection & Fit
• Draft Range: Priority Free Agent.
• NFL Comparison: Similar to Thomas Morstead (early-career profile) — reliable, technically sound punter without elite power.
• Best Fit: Teams seeking a developmental punter with consistency and control, especially for directional and situational punting.
Key Takeaway
James Platte is a technically sound punter with reliable mechanics and situational control. While his leg strength may not match top-tier prospects, his consistency and ability to flip field position give him a chance to compete for a roster spot as a developmental punter at the next level.
*A “lefty”. It’s might be silly, but quite a few hours later and this dude’s ability to perfectly place a punt is still impressed upon me.
-
Raidernation1979
- Posts: 8,065
- Joined: Fri Dec 12, 2014 4:39 am
- Has given High Fives: 385 times
- Received High Fives: 882 times
Lots of return guys. Clearly that area is inportant to them. Thank god. We haven’t had a good returner since cribbs? We have seriously lacked there
- These users gave a High Five to the author Raidernation1979 for the post:
- KillerRaider30
-
Raider_Dave
- Posts: 3,445
- Joined: Fri Oct 31, 2014 4:22 pm
- Has given High Fives: 4 times
- Received High Fives: 191 times
WTF... isn't there a limit to how many of these guys you can take?
I think I see now. A number of these guys are just invited to a rookie minicamp tryout.
I think I see now. A number of these guys are just invited to a rookie minicamp tryout.
-
GoodTimeCharlie
- Posts: 4,584
- Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
- Location: Atop the commode
- Has given High Fives: 1483 times
- Received High Fives: 1350 times
If I’ve got it right, 8 UDFA and 27 Minicamp invites.Raider_Dave wrote: Sun Apr 26, 2026 6:48 pm WTF... isn't there a limit to how many of these guys you can take?
I think I see now. A number of these guys are just invited to a rookie minicamp tryout.
- These users gave a High Five to the author GoodTimeCharlie for the post:
- Raider_Dave
-
RunOverByHubbard
- Posts: 13,103
- Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2013 9:09 am
- Location: 88 miles NE of the Coliseum
- Has given High Fives: 106 times
- Received High Fives: 574 times
Oh -- I was wondering if we were signing all these guys. So they are all invited to our minicamp, or are these prospects who have not signed with anyone yet? You probably explained that a while back and I missed it.
Here is our signees per NFL.com:
QB Jacob Clark
RB Roman Hemby
WR Chase Roberts
WR E.J. Williams Jr.
OT Isaiah Jatta
DT Gary Smith III
S Tanner Wall
K Kansei Matsuzawa
LS Tyler Duzansky
Here is our signees per NFL.com:
QB Jacob Clark
RB Roman Hemby
WR Chase Roberts
WR E.J. Williams Jr.
OT Isaiah Jatta
DT Gary Smith III
S Tanner Wall
K Kansei Matsuzawa
LS Tyler Duzansky
